Heritage New Zealand bestows highest level of recognition on disputed Ihumātao land

5:36 pm on 27 February 2020

The disputed land at Ihumātao has been granted the highest level of heritage recognition, but the largely symbolic decision will not bring the conflict to an end.

People continue to occupy Ihumatao after protestors were served an eviction notice which led to a stand-off with police.

People occupying Ihumātao after protestors were served an eviction notice which led to a stand-off with police last year. Photo: RNZ / Dan Cook

Heritage New Zealand will tomorrow announce that it has extended the borders of the Ōtuataua Stonefields reserve in Māngere to include the controversial whenua.

The new area will also have its status increased from category 2 to category 1 - the highest listing available.

In a letter published online by protest leader Pania Newton, Heritage New Zealand said its review process had generated "unprecedented levels of interest and comment".

More than 1500 people submitted, many of whom requested the outstanding significance of the land be appropriately recognised, the letter read.

"Many also commented on the desirability of long-term protection of this historic place," the letter read.

The increased heritage status serves a symbolic and educational purpose, but does not grant any greater protections. Decisions of that sort are decided by a process involving consultation, public hearings and independent commissioners.

As such, the status of the special housing area or any existing resource consent on the land remains intact, meaning it could still be used to build housing.

Fletcher Building purchased the land in 2014 for a planned housing development, but protesters from the Save Our Unique Landscape (SOUL) movement say it should be returned to Māori.

In July last year, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern called for a halt to any building work while the government and other parties tried to broker a solution.

In a statement, Finance Minister Grant Robertson said the government was still searching for a resolution that respected all parties, including the Crown, mana whenua, and Fletchers.

"Heritage NZ is an independent statutory entity and this is their decision, which will now go to Auckland Council for further consideration," Robertson said.

Heritage NZ and Newton have both been approached by RNZ for comment.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs