Filled with pride: Winner of Supreme Pie Award announced

7:35 am on 31 July 2019

These hand-sized parcels of filled pastry mean a great deal to our little country, so to be adjudged the maker of the best pie in New Zealand is surely up there with getting a knighthood or Nobel prize.

No caption

Dozens of bakers and chefs examined over 5000 pies. Photo: Photo /Supplied

It's understandable, then, to see the surgical precision with which judges of the Bakels NZ Supreme Pie Awards go about their work.

"We want a good looking pie on the top and we actually want to see that flow right through down the side down to the bottom of the pie, making sure the base is clean," said Sean Armstrong, who ate an admirable 22 pies during last year's competition.

"By looking at the inside it allows us to check out the thickness of the base. So we can tell if you put too much pastry on the bottom. Is it raw? All those sorts of things. And it allows us to look at the flake of puff pastry on the top."

And the winner: the mince and cheese pie from Goldstar Patrick's Pies in Tauranga and Rotorua, last night been judged as the best pie in New Zealand.

The mince and cheese pie from Goldstar Patrick's Pies.

The mince and cheese pie from Goldstar Patrick's Pies. Photo: Supplied / Bakels NZ

Dozens of bakers and chefs rigourously examined more than 5000 pies to come to their decision.

Chief judge Tim Aspinell has been involved with the competition for 23 years.

So is he sick of the sight of pies?

"Never," he said. "I like the pie concept where you've got a meal on the run. If you need something to eat, you've got to have something to eat and people don't tend to think of the goods and the bads of it. I'm hungry. What is good? A pie is good."

Five-hundred-and-sixty bakeries entered the competition and Bakels managing director Brent Kersel said pies were brought in from all over the country.

"We get people flying in from the South Island - they put them on their lap and bring them up on the plane - and we have people come from Wellington," he said.

"Most of the Auckland people would deliver them themselves so that last hour before close-off at five o'clock there's a lot of cars turning up with their pies."

As well as winning $7500 prize money, the supreme winner can expect to have queues pouring out of their shop for the rest of their days.

"The man we call the Pie King, Pat Lam, he's won it six times and and you've only got to go down to his business in Bethlehem to see how successful he is.

"I was down there the other week and people were lined up outside the door at 10 o'clock waiting for their pies. It doesn't just grow their pie category, it grows the whole business."

Gold winners of each category:

  • Supreme winner (mince and cheese) - Patrick Lam - Goldstar Patrick's Pies - Tauranga
  • Mince and gravy - Heng Seanghy - Oliver's Bakehouse - Mission Bay, Auckland
  • Potato topped - Bunna Hout - Euro Patisserie Torbay - Torbay, Auckland
  • Steak and cheese - Michael Gray - Nada Bakery - Tawa, Wellington
  • Chicken and vegetable - Jason Danielson - Kai Pai Wholesale - Wanaka
  • Cafe boutique - poached rhubarb and blueberry pie from Mike Sproule of Original Foods - Wigram, Christchurch
  • Gourmet meat - Moroccan lamb pie from Ty Lim of Orewa Bakery - Orewa
  • Truckie and tradie (steak and gravy) - Bunna Hout - Euro Patisserie Torbay - Torbay, Auckland
  • Bacon and egg - Patrick Lam - Goldstar Patrick's Pies - Tauranga
  • Gourmet fruit - Blackforest pie from John Kloeg of Ten O'Clock Cookie Bakery Cafe - Masterton
  • Vegetarian - Broccoli, cauliflower, pumpkin, carrot, and spinach pie from Bunna Hout of Euro Patisserie Torbay - Torbay, Auckland
  • Commercial wholesale mince and cheese - Tim Milinia - Oxford Pies - Pukete, Hamilton