Security increased to protect moa sites as trading loopholes reviewed

11:05 am on 1 August 2019

Security has been beefed up at caves where moa bones are at risk of being pillaged, as the government moves to make it illegal to trade remains of the extinct bird.

A moa skull and foot bones of undisclosed provenance sold on TradeMe for almost $3000 dollars.

A moa skull and foot bones of undisclosed provenance sold on TradeMe for almost $3000 dollars. Photo: Photo / TradeMe

Conservation Minister Eugenie Sage said more cameras with remote alarm sensors had been installed to protect archaeological sites from looters trying to make a quick buck.

This is ahead of the government's plans to consult the public about possible regulation changes to stop the trade of moa bones.

"People are trifling with the law if they think they can get away with taking moa bones from sites," she said.

"We would encourage people to recognise that moa full skeletons in museums and other scientific institutions are really valuable. Selling bits of skeletons, bones, on TradeMe and elsewhere reduces the availability for scientific institutions to have these whole skeletons."

Not a single kiwi feather can be traded and yet the remains of one of the world's rarest extinct bird species continue to be bought and sold on the open market.

Just this week, a moa skull and foot bones of undisclosed provenance sold on TradeMe for almost $3000.

Legislation protects native species from being traded but a loophole means some remains of extinct species are fair game. It is illegal to trade the remains of extinct species only if they are found on protected land or archaeological sites - and experts say most sites where moa bones are taken from are protected.

Green Party MP Eugenie Sage, Minister of Conservation

Conservation Minister Eugenie Sage says more cameras with remote alarm sensors had been installed to protect archaeological sites from looters. Photo: VNP / Phil Smith

Anyone who removes objects from public conservation land without authority faces up to five years imprisonment or a $300,000 fine for offences committed for commercial gain.

The ongoing trade in moa bones and eggshells has been getting under paleantologists' skin for years, as skeletons are sold piecemeal and important information about New Zealand's history is lost.

Curators pushed regulations

Two years ago, curators from six of New Zealand's museums wrote to the Department of Conservation outlining why regulations need to change.

The Department of Conservation is now preparing a public discussion document for the government, in consultation with museums, with a view to putting in place regulations.

Former museum curator Dr Mike Dickison said although he was pleased the government was addressing the problem, regulation changes needed to be fast-tracked.

He said museum curators had also asked TradeMe to stop selling moa remains.

"TradeMe could shut the whole dodgy moa bone trade down tomorrow if they wanted to, since almost all of it is happening on their website," Dr Dickison said.

"We've asked them to do this for years with no movement. They could do something enormously valuable by stopping the trade immediately and that would shut down any last minute folks trying to make a quick buck."

TradeMe's trust and safety team leader James Ryan said there had been about 10 listings for moa bones on its site in the last year.

He said so long as it was legal to sell moa remains found on private land, the site would continue to sell them.

Dr Dickison said the country's museum curators refused to buy moa bones or verify their provenance because they did not believe the remains should be sold.

He said most moa bones were sold on TradeMe and despite being asked by the museum fraternity, the trading platform had so far refused to shut down such sales.

"Museums have refused to authenticate or identify bones that are put up on TradeMe, even though sellers will lie and say that this bone has been authenticated or just call the local museum who'll confirm it's a moa bone," Dr Dickison said.

"They don't want this trade happening because so much material's being destroyed and split up and we know that protected sites are being looted of bones by people who just want some quick money."

Department of Conservation senior policy advisor Michael Gee said they aimed to submit the public discussion document with the Conservation Minister by August.