Last two Australian correspondents pulled out of China

2:17 pm on 8 September 2020

The ABC and the Australian Financial Review have rushed their correspondents out of China after police demanded interviews with both journalists, resulting in an extraordinary diplomatic standoff.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation journalist Bill Birtles waving as he arrives in Sydney on September 8, 2020, after leaving China amid worsening diplomatic relations between the two countries.

Australian Broadcasting Corporation journalist Bill Birtles waving as he arrives in Sydney on September 8, 2020, after leaving China amid worsening diplomatic relations between the two countries. Photo: AFP / Taryn Southcombe via AFP

Bill Birtles, the ABC's correspondent based in Beijing, and Mike Smith, the AFR's correspondent based in Shanghai, boarded a flight to Sydney last night after the pair were questioned separately by China's Ministry of State security.

Birtles had spent four days sheltering in the Australian Embassy in Beijing, while Smith took refuge in the Australian Consulate in Shanghai as diplomats negotiated with Chinese officials to allow them to safely leave the country.

The saga began early last week, when Australian diplomats in Beijing cautioned Birtles that he should leave China, with officials from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade giving the same advice to ABC's managing director David Anderson in Sydney.

Subsequent advice prompted the ABC to organise flights back to Australia for Birtles. He was due to depart last Thursday morning.

But the threatening behaviour from Chinese officials peaked before he could leave, when seven police officers arrived at Birtles' apartment at midnight last Wednesday as he was holding farewell drinks with friends and colleagues.

They told him he was banned from leaving the country, and that he would be contacted the next day to organise a time to be questioned over a "national security case".

Birtles called the Australian Embassy and arranged to be collected from his apartment. He stayed in the Beijing diplomatic compound for the next few days, where he was contacted by Chinese officials demanding an interview.

He initially refused to speak with them, citing fears for his personal safety.

Birtles was interviewed by Chinese authorities on Sunday, accompanied by Australian Ambassador to China Graham Fletcher, after an agreement was reached between Australian and Chinese officials that his travel ban would be lifted if he spoke to them.

During the meeting, no questions were asked about his reporting or conduct in China.

Birtles was told by embassy officials after the interview that his travel ban had been rescinded. He was joined by consular staff on a flight from Beijing to Shanghai early on Monday, where he waited for his flight to Sydney.

AFR correspondent Smith was subjected to questioning on Monday evening, after sheltering in the Australian consulate in Shanghai. The AFR made similar arrangements to get him out of the country.

After touching down in Sydney, Birtles said the experience had been a "whirlwind".

"It's very disappointing to have to leave under those circumstances, and it's a relief to be back in a country with a genuine rule of law," he said.

"This was a whirlwind, and it's not a particularly good experience.

"It's just good to be home."

The drama came only days after China's Government publicly confirmed the arrest of an Australian journalist working for China's state media, Cheng Lei.

Tense relationship between China and Australia

The unprecedented standoff marks another deterioration in the Australia-China relationship, already buffeted by tensions over trade, espionage, Hong Kong and the coronavirus pandemic.

A Chinese paramilitary police officer gestures while standing at the entrance gate of the Australian embassy in Beijing on July 9, 2020.

A Chinese paramilitary police officer gestures while standing at the entrance gate of the Australian embassy in Beijing on July 9, 2020. Photo: AFP / Nicolas Asfouri

In July, the Australian Government changed its travel advice for China, warning Australian citizens faced "arbitrary detention" on the mainland.

ABC managing director David Anderson in Sydney has been in contact with DFAT and Foreign Minister Marise Payne's office since the initial warning was issued last week.

ABC News director Gaven Morris said Birtles was being brought home following advice from the Australian Government.

"This bureau is a vital part of the ABC's international newsgathering effort and we aim to get back there as soon as possible," Mr Morris said in a statement.

"The story of China, its relationship with Australia and its role in our region and in the world is one of great importance for all Australians and we want to continue having our people on the ground to cover it."

AFR editor-in-chief Michael Stutchbury and editor Paul Bailey issued a statement welcoming the duo's safe return.

"We are glad Mike Smith, our correspondent who has been based in Shanghai for two-and-a-half years, and Bill Birtles from the ABC, have made a safe return to Australian this morning," they said.

"This incident targeting two journalists, who were going about their normal reporting duties, is both regrettable and disturbing and is not in the interests of a co-operative relationship between Australia and China.

"Thank you to the Department of Foreign Affair and Trade and Consular officials who assisted in their safe return."

The Foreign Minister said Australia's travel warnings for China remained unchanged.

"We encourage all Australians who are overseas, or are seeking to travel, to closely monitor Smartraveller.

"The Australian Government continues to provide consular support to Australian citizens detained in China, including Ms Cheng Lei."

Opposition foreign affairs spokeswoman Penny Wong said the news was "very disturbing" .

"I would just make a point that it is regrettable that news organisations, including the ABC, have had to make this decision," she told ABC Radio Adelaide.

"The reports are deeply concerning, particularly some of the suggestions about what occurred prior to Mr Birtles leaving and Mr Smith leaving."

Move leaves no Australian media in China

The evacuation means for the first time since the mid-1970s there are no accredited Australian media journalists in China, with correspondent for The Australian Will Glasgow also out of the country.

China has not issued new visas for journalists from the ABC and Nine newspapers.

The move against Birtles and Smith comes in the wake of a broader crackdown on Western journalists in China.

In March, Beijing expelled 14 American journalists working at the New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post in retaliation for the Trump Administration's decision to restrict staff at Chinese state media outlets in the United States.

The ABC's Beijing bureau opened in 1973, shortly after Australia normalised relations with China under prime minister Gough Whitlam.

ABC correspondents have been witnesses to a variety of major international stories from the bureau, including the Tiananmen Square massacre, the 2008 Olympics, pro-democracy protests in Hong Kong and the coronavirus outbreak.

Run-ins with Chinese authorities have been regular and frequent, with a number of correspondents being questioned by authorities while pursuing stories.


Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs