9 Feb 2019

Black Caps dumbfounded by DRS blunder

12:15 pm on 9 February 2019

The Black Caps have been left dumbfounded by a Decision Review System blunder in the second Twenty20 cricket international against India at Eden Park.

Daryl Mitchell is given out LBW and heads back to the dressing room.
New Zealand Black Caps v India. Twenty20 International cricket. 2nd T20. Eden Park, Auckland, New Zealand. Friday 8 February 2019. © Copyright photo: Andrew Cornaga / www.photosport.nz

Photo: Photosport Ltd 2019

Rookie New Zealand all-rounder Daryl Mitchell was given out LBW by TV umpire Shaun Haig, despite HotSpot showing a clear mark on his bat as a delivery from Krunal Pandya passed the inside edge. Ball-tracking also showed a deviation as ball passed bat.

Black Caps leg-spinner Ish Sodhi summed up the team's sentiment.

"Shocking. I genuinely didn't really understand what was going on," Sodhi said.

"I think most people saw that there was a hot spot on the bat and I guess that's how we felt.

"We were pretty gutted about it. Gutted for Daryl you know, second game coming out and seeing something that I've never seen in international cricket before."

Mitchell and Black Caps captain Kane Williamson, who was at the non-striker's end at the time of the dismissal, both were visibly perplexed by the decision.

Daryl Mitchell is given out as Kane Williamson and India's MS Dhoni and Rohit Sharma look on.
New Zealand Black Caps v India. Twenty20 International cricket. 2nd T20. Eden Park, Auckland, New Zealand. Friday 8 February 2019. © Copyright photo: Andrew Cornaga / www.photosport.nz

Photo: Photosport Ltd 2019

Williamson questioned the umpires out in the middle who then talked to India captain Rohit Sharma before Mitchell was sent on his way.

India pace bowler Khaleel Ahmed said that the India players accepted the umpire's decision on face value.

"We were just waiting for the umpire's call, because we can't do anything in that decision," Khaleel said

"So we were just waiting for that decision. Whatever the umpire said, we accepted it."

The ICC rules indicate a fielding captain can withdraw an appeal if he gets the permission to do so from the umpire who made the decision, and the next ball of the game hasn't been delivered yet.

India went on to win the match by seven wickets beat the Black Caps, levelling the series and setting up a decider in Hamilton tomorrow.

-RNZ