6 Aug 2015

Safety first, privacy second, says Adams

1:03 pm on 6 August 2015

Safety concerns should trump privacy so people can be saved from domestic violence, the Justice Minister Amy Adams says.

The Government has launched a blueprint for an overhaul of domestic violence laws.

The Government has launched a blueprint for an overhaul of domestic violence laws. Photo: RNZ / Kim Baker Wilson

The Government has launched a blueprint for a comprehensive overhaul of domestic violence laws in Auckland.

Ms Adams said she wanted to kick-start national debate about the "horrifically high" rate of domestic violence, which sees an incident reported to police every five minutes.

"In the same time it takes to order a coffee, one traumatised victim somewhere in New Zealand is taking a courageous step in reporting to police the abuse they've endured often countless times before.

"Vulnerable New Zealanders are battling in dark and terrifying corners around the country and confronting the scourge of violence in a very real and harrowing way," the minister said.

Ms Adams conceded some of the ideas in the discussion document were controversial, but said things had to be done differently to get different results.

She said 20 years ago the New Zealand domestic violence laws were world-leaders, but that things had changed since then.

Ms Adams said police often knew when people were serious, repeat offenders.

"One of the things we are looking at is the way they can advise people who are considered to be at high-risk of violence of that harm before it happens.

"I absolutely accept these are a big departure from the culture we're in, where privacy trumps everything... If we want to get real in-roads to this we're going to have to look at some things that are bit edgy."

Support from Shine

The country's largest anti-domestic abuse charity, Shine, said the blueprint for overhauling family violence laws raised exciting opportunities.

Executive director Jane Drumm said the possibility of over-riding privacy laws would be useful.

"Why wait until something terrible has happened? When everyone knows that there could be a child at risk, or adult at risk; and often very vulnerable adults."

Ms Drumm said the discussion document could help New Zealand become a world leader on curbing domestic abuse.

National MP, Amy Adams.

National MP, Amy Adams. Photo: RNZ / Alexander Robertson

The discussion document, Strengthening New Zealand's Legislative Response to Family Violence, is almost 60 pages long.

Ms Adams said she wanted to make sure the law could effectively hold the perpetrators of domestic violence to account in a co-ordinated way.

Because of this, the review would cover many pieces of legislation.

'Staggering, sobering statistics'

Ms Adams said the figures for domestic violence in New Zealand were, "staggering, sobering and persistently and stubbornly high".

A recently-released stock-take of services across all government agencies found that $1.4 billion was spent each year on family and sexual violence.

It is thought as many as nine out of every ten incidents were not reported, and yet police still fielded 100,000 family violence reports last year.

The audit found 41 percent of police response time was spent on domestic violence.

The discussion document is open for feedback until 18 September.

Ideas in the discussion document

  • Establishing a set of stand alone family violence offences.
  • Creating an additional pathway for victims, perpetrators and whānau who want help to stop violence, but do not want to have to go to court.
  • Ideas about improving the accessibility and effectiveness of protection orders.
  • Doing a better job of sharing information where family violence concerns arise between agencies and within the courts.
  • Considering compelling police action in certain circumstances such as requiring mandatory arrest for all breaches of protection orders.
  • More prominence to victim safety in related legislation such as the Care of Children Act and bail and sentencing law.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs