Karla Cardno's killer Paul Joseph Dally again denied parole

4:32 pm on 8 May 2025
Kohuora Auckland South Corrections Facility, a SERCO run high security men’s prison located at Wiri, in Auckland.

Paul Joseph Dally has been at the self-care unit at Auckland South Corrections Facility, with a minimum security classification Photo: RNZ / Sam Olley

In a decision released on Thursday, the parole board remained concerned about the level of support available to Dally while he reintegrated, but work was underway to prepare him for that.

He was sentenced to life imprisonment on 8 March 1990, and for the past year had been held in a self-care unit at Auckland South Corrections Facility, with a minimum security classification.

When he appeared before the parole board in June 2024, it heard about his efforts to prepare for an eventual release - but on that date, he did not seek parole

By now aged in his mid 60s, he was told to expect a very different world than the one he had known - one where people used cards rather than cash, and bought their food from modern supermarkets.

His lawyer, Emma Priest, submitted in April that, while her client was not seeking parole, he was "almost ready," although he remained dependent on support from his case manager to prepare for reintegration.

At the time, the board found Dally's safety plan inadequate.

He appeared before the board again in April, and according to the parole board decision released on Thursday, he had been engaging with a senior psychologist on understanding his risks, warning signs and coping strategies.

But the board denied him parole once again, largely due to issues around accommodation.

"A central issue that is still to be determined is Mr Dally's accommodation arrangements when he returns to the community," the decision reads.

The board had "considerable doubt" that the required level of support and oversight necessary in Dally's case would be available.

He could appear before the parole board again in six months' time, by 31 October, which the board hoped would provide sufficient time to complete his work with the psychologist, and with his case manager in developing his release plan.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs