22 Jan 2020

Australia fires: Malcolm Turnbull criticises Scott Morrison over climate change stance

8:13 pm on 22 January 2020

Australian PM Scott Morrison has been accused of lacking leadership during the bushfire crisis by the man he replaced after a party room coup.

Malcolm Turnbull, who was deposed in 2018, told the BBC that Morrison had misled the country by "downplaying" the influence of global warming.

Morrison apologised last month for taking a US holiday amid the fires. He has insisted his policies are adequate.

Turnbull said he "cannot explain" his successor's approach.

In a wide-ranging interview, Turnbull also said US President Donald Trump was the world's "leading climate denier" and that America's lack of leadership was "extremely damaging".

Turnbull said "everybody knew we were in a very dry time" before the fire season, and that it "was likely to be very bad".

"Rather than doing what a leader should do... [Morrison] downplayed it, and at times discounted the influence of climate change, which is just nonsense from a scientific point of view. So that's misleading people," Turnbull said.

"Then of course [he] chose to go away on holiday in Hawaii at the peak of the crisis. So I can't explain any of that.

"It's just not consistent with the way in which a prime minister would or should act in a national crisis like this."

Since September, bushfires have scarred Australia. At least 30 people have died, livelihoods have been lost along with thousands of homes, and there have been untold catastrophic effects on wildlife.

Morrison has conceded he caused "great anxiety in Australia" by taking his family to the US as record-breaking heat exacerbated fires.

"I know there are some who've tried to make political points and score points in the midst of these disasters, and that's disappointing," he said before Christmas.

He asserted that climate change was "one of many factors" responsible for the blazes.

Australia's Prime Minister Scott Morrison (C) visits a resident's property in an area devastated by bushfires in Sarsfield, Victoria state on January 3, 2020.

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison Photo: AFP

As the fires have raged, so has the debate about climate change and its part in Australia's destructive summer.

Turnbull took aim at former colleagues in the governing Liberal Party, accusing another ex-prime minister Tony Abbott of being "probably the most prominent climate denier in Australian politics, but there are plenty of others" who were engaged in a "war against science".

"It is an extraordinarily irrational and self-destructive approach," Turnbull said.

Turnbull's prime ministership began in 2015 when he removed Abbott, a long-time rival. He was in power for three years before being ousted in similar fashion.

It was a fevered period in Australian politics, and Turnbull was castigated by a senior minister as being spiteful and indecisive. He also faced criticism externally for not doing more while in power.

Shortly before he was replaced, Turnbull abandoned his government's flagship energy policy in a last-ditch concession to his party's right wing.

Former Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull.


The policy would have set in legislation Australia's emissions target, which has long been criticised as inadequate for a wealthy nation. The 2030 target of a 26 percent reduction on 2005 levels is one of the weakest among G20 nations.

The University of Oxford graduate, former barrister and banker told the BBC he was the victim of a ruthless political insurgency.

"The right [wing] in the Liberal Party essentially operate like terrorists," he said.

"Now I'm not suggesting that they use guns and bombs or anything like that, but their approach is one of intimidation.

"And they basically say to the rest of the party ... if you don't do what we want, we will blow the show up. Famously one of the coup leaders said to me, 'you have to give in to the terrorists'."

In Turnbull's offices overlooking Sydney's harbour are small-framed photographs of himself with world leaders: former US president Barack Obama, Indian PM Narendra Modi and Indonesian president Joko Widodo.

There is also a picture with US President Donald Trump. Not so much a happy snap - the pair famously clashed over a refugee swap deal and there's hostility, too, over the environment.

US President Donald Trump addresses the World Economic Forum in Davos, on January 21, 2020.

US President Donald Trump Photo: Jim Watson / AFP

"Trump is playing a very destructive role in terms of climate action. Trump makes no bones about it. He says global warming is rubbish," Turnbull said.

"Trump is trying to put a brake on global action to reduce emissions. The lack of American leadership is extremely damaging."

"How many more coral reefs have to be bleached? How many more million hectares of forest have to be burned?

"How many more lives and homes have to be lost before the climate change deniers acknowledge they are wrong?"