25 Jun 2023

Titan sub CEO dismissed safety warnings as 'baseless cries', emails show

6:13 am on 25 June 2023
This undated image courtesy of OceanGate Expeditions, shows their Titan submersible being towed to a dive location in Everett, Washington. Rescue teams expanded their search underwater on June 20, 2023, as they raced against time to find a Titan deep-diving tourist submersible that went missing near the wreck of the Titanic with five people on board and limited oxygen. All communication was lost with the 21-foot (6.5-meter) Titan craft during a descent June 18 to the Titanic, which sits at a depth of crushing pressure more than two miles (nearly four kilometers) below the surface of the North Atlantic.

The Titan is believed to have imploded while on a deep sea dive to the wreck of the Titanic. Photo: AFP / OceanGate Expeditions

By Rebecca Morelle, Alison Francis & Gareth Evans for BBC News

Warnings over the safety of OceanGate's Titan submersible were repeatedly dismissed by the head of the company, email exchanges with a leading deep sea exploration specialist show.

In messages seen by the BBC, Rob McCallum told OceanGate chief executive Stockton Rush he was potentially putting his clients at risk and urged him to stop using the sub until it had been certified by an independent agency.

Rush responded that he was "tired of industry players who try to use a safety argument to stop innovation".

The tense exchange ended after OceanGate's lawyers threatened legal action, McCallum said.

"I think you are potentially placing yourself and your clients in a dangerous dynamic," he wrote to the OceanGate boss in March 2018. "In your race to Titanic you are mirroring that famous catch cry: 'She is unsinkable.'"

In the messages, Rush, who was among five passengers who died when the Titan experienced what officials believe was a "catastrophic implosion" on Sunday, expresses frustration with the criticism of Titan's safety measures.

"We have heard the baseless cries of 'you are going to kill someone' way too often," he wrote. "I take this as a serious personal insult."

McCallum told the BBC he repeatedly urged the company to seek certification for the Titan before using it for commercial tours. The vessel was never certified or classed.

This combination of pictures created on June 21, 2023 shows Titan submersible passengers (L-R, top to bottom) Hamish Harding, in an image courtesy of Dirty Dozen Productions, ahead of the 4am start of the RMS Titanic Expedition Mission 5 on June 18, 2023. A portrait courtesy of OceanGate Expeditions of their CEO and founder Stockton Rush. A May 31, 2013, file photo of Paul-Henri Nargeolet, director of a deep ocean research project dedicated to the Titanic, in Paris. An
undated image courtesy of the Dawood Hercules Corporation released on June 20, 2023, of Suleman Dawood and his father Shahzada Dawood, vice-chairman of Karachi-headquartered conglomerate Engro.
Rescuers searching for the Titan near the wreck of the Titanic have detected "underwater noises" in the search area, the US Coast Guard said June 21, 2023, with the five on board estimated to have less than 24 hours of oxygen left.
Handout, Joël SAGET / AFP / Dirty Dozen Productions / OceanGate Expeditions / DAWOOD HERCULES CORPORATION

Stockton Rush (top right) was founder and chief executive of OceanGate, the company that launched the tragic deep sea expedition. The Titan was carrying (clockwise) Rush, Suleman Dawood and his father Shahzada Dawood, Paul-Henri Nargeolet and Hamish Harding. Photo: Handout, Joël SAGET / AFP / Dirty Dozen Productions / OceanGate Expeditions / DAWOOD HERCULES CORPORATION

"Until a sub is classed, tested and proven it should not be used for commercial deep dive operations," he wrote in one email.

"I implore you to take every care in your testing and sea trials and to be very, very conservative," he added. "As much as I appreciate entrepreneurship and innovation, you are potentially putting an entire industry at risk."

In his response a few days later, Rush defended his business and his credentials.

He said OceanGate's "engineering focused, innovative approach... flies in the face of the submersible orthodoxy, but that is the nature of innovation".

Throughout the exchange, Rush defended his qualifications and questioned the existing framework around deep sea expeditions.

He said "industry players" were trying to stop "new entrants from entering their small existing market".

"I am well qualified to understand the risks and issues associated with subsea exploration in a new vehicle," he wrote.

No caption

Rob McCallum Photo: supplied

McCallum then responded in stark terms, writing: "It will be sea trials that determine whether the vehicle can handle what you intend to do with it so again; take care and keep safe."

"There is a lot more riding on this than Titan and the Titanic," he said.

Rush founded OceanGate in 2009 and the company offered customers a chance to experience deep sea travel, including to the wreck of the Titanic, on board Titan for a price of US$250,000 (NZ$400,000).

The BBC said OceanGate had not commented on the email exchange.

In emails supplied to the BBC, leading deep sea exploration specialist Rob McCallum raised serious safety concerns with Stockton Rush.

In emails supplied to the BBC, leading deep sea exploration specialist Rob McCallum raised serious safety concerns with Stockton Rush. Photo: Supplied via BBC

In emails supplied to the BBC, leading deep sea exploration specialist Rob McCallum raised serious safety concerns with Stockton Rush.

Photo: Supplied via BBC

Experts have questioned the safety of Titan and how private sector deep-sea expeditions are regulated. Concerns have been raised over the Titan's experimental design and the carbon fibre material used to build it.

McCallum was among more than three dozen industry leaders and experts who signed a 2018 letter to Rush that warned OceanGate's approach could lead to "catastrophic" problems.

"The industry has been trying for several years to get Stockton Rush to halt his programme for two reasons," McCallum, a specialist who runs his own ocean expedition company, told the BBC on Friday.

"One is that carbon fibre is not an acceptable material," he said. "The other is that this was the only submersible in the world doing commercial work that was unclassed. It was not certified by an independent agency."

Subs can be certified or "classed" by marine organisations - for example by the American Bureau of Shipping (ABS) or DNV (a global accreditation organisation based in Norway) or Lloyd's Register.

This essentially means that the vehicle must meet certain standards on aspects including stability, strength, safety and performance. But this process is not mandatory.

In a blog post in 2019, the company said the way it had been designed fell outside of the accepted system - but it "does not mean that OceanGate does not meet standards where they apply."

"Stockton fancied himself as somewhat of a maverick entrepreneur," McCallum said. "He liked to think outside the box, didn't like to be penned in by rules. But there are rules - and then there are sound engineering principles and the laws of physics."

McCallum maintains that nobody should have travelled in the Titan sub.

"If you steer away from sound engineering principles, which are all based on hard won experience, there is a price to pay, and it's a terrible price," he said. "So it should never be allowed to happen again. It shouldn't have been allowed to happen this time."

- This story was first published by the BBC.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs