17 Nov 2022

NATO, Poland say missile was Ukrainian stray, easing fears of wider war

1:38 pm on 17 November 2022
President of Poland Andrzej Duda seen during Polish National Security Council in response to shells explosion in Przewodow village in Lubelskie voivodeship in Warsaw on 16 November, 2022.

Polish President Andrzej Duda says it is "highly probable" the missile that landed in Poland, killing two, was fired by Ukrainian anti-aircraft defence. Photo: AFP

A missile that crashed inside Poland was probably a stray fired by Ukraine's air defences and not a Russian strike, according to Poland and military alliance NATO, easing international fears that the war could spill across the border.

Nevertheless, NATO's chief said that Russia, not Ukraine, was still to blame for starting the war in the first place with its February invasion and launching scores of missiles on Tuesday that triggered Ukrainian defences.

"This is not Ukraine's fault. Russia bears ultimate responsibility as it continues its illegal war against Ukraine," NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg told reporters in Brussels.

NATO ambassadors held emergency talks to respond to Tuesday's blast that killed two people at a grain facility in Poland near the Ukrainian border, the war's first deadly extension into the territory of the Western alliance.

"From the information that we and our allies have, it was an S-300 rocket made in the Soviet Union, an old rocket and there is no evidence that it was launched by the Russian side," Polish President Andrzej Duda said. "It is highly probable that it was fired by Ukrainian anti-aircraft defence."

Stoltenberg also said it was likely to have been a Ukrainian air defence missile. Earlier, US President Joe Biden had said the trajectories suggested the missile was unlikely to have been unleashed from Russia.

North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) secretary general Jens Stoltenberg speaks to the press during an European Foreign Affairs Council (Defence) at the European Council headquarters.

North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) secretary general Jens Stoltenberg. Photo: AFP

'Not our missile' - Zelensky

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky demurred, saying "I have no doubt that it was not our missile", Ukrainian media reported on Wednesday. He said he based his conclusion on reports from Ukraine's military which he "cannot but trust".

He gave no evidence for his position and, in a nightly video address, urged that Ukraine be included in the investigation of the explosion site in Poland in order to determine the facts.

Asked about the discrepancy in accounts from Ukraine, Poland and NATO, a State Department spokesperson in Washington said, "We are aware of President Zelensky's comments ... but we do not have any information that would contradict Poland's preliminary findings."

The incident occurred while Russia was firing scores of missiles at cities across Ukraine, targeting its energy grid and worsening power blackouts for millions, in what Kyiv says was the most intense volley of such strikes of the nine-month war.

Kyiv says it shot down most of the incoming Russian missiles with its own air defence systems. Ukraine's Volyn region, just across the border from Poland, was one of the many Ukraine says was targeted by Russia's countrywide fusillade.

The Russian Defence Ministry said none of its missiles had struck closer than 35 km (20 miles) from the Polish border, and that photos of the wreckage in Poland showed elements of a Ukrainian S-300 air defence missile. Poland has said it was probably an old S-300 rocket, a Soviet-era missile system being used by both Russia and Ukraine.

The Kremlin said on Wednesday some countries had made "baseless statements" about the incident, after having accused Poland of an "absolutely hysterical" reaction on Tuesday, but that Washington had been comparatively restrained.

Russia's Foreign Ministry said the "mayhem" around accusations of Russian involvement were "part of a systematic anti-Russian campaign by the West."

Zelensky also said Kyiv had received no offer from Moscow to start peace talks, and top adviser Mykhailo Podoloyak dismissed the notion of talks. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said earlier this week Ukraine was not interested in such talks.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky meets with Director General of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Rafael Grossi (not seen) in Kyiv, Ukraine on 30 August, 2022.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said he had "no doubt" the missile was not fired by his military. File photo. Photo: AFP


The news that Western officials had concluded the missile was Ukrainian brought some relief to the inhabitants of the Polish village hit by the missile, with some saying they had feared being dragged into the war.

"Everyone has in the back of the head that we are right near the border and that an armed conflict with Russia would expose us directly," said Grzegorz Drewnik, the mayor of Dolhobyczow, the municipality to which Przewodow belongs.

"If this is a mistake of the Ukrainians, there should be no major consequences, but I'm not an expert here."

Some Western leaders at a summit of the G20 big economies in Indonesia suggested that whoever fired the missile, Russia and President Vladimir Putin would ultimately be held responsible for an incident arising from its invasion.

G20 leaders issued a closing declaration saying "most members strongly condemned the war in Ukraine", although it acknowledged that "there were other views".

Moscow carried out Tuesday's missile volley just days after abandoning the southern city of Kherson, the only regional capital it had captured since the invasion.

The barrage echoed a pattern of Moscow lashing out with longer-range missile salvoes after losses on the battlefield to a continuing Ukrainian counter-offensive in the east and south.

However, the top US general played down the chances of any near-term, outright military victory by Ukraine, cautioning that Russia still had significant combat power inside Ukraine despite a string of setbacks.

"Politically, there may be a political solution where, politically, the Russians withdraw. That's possible," Army General Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told a news conference in Washington.

Russia "right now is on its back", Milley added.

- Reuters

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs