23 Jan 2019

Hong Kong debates outlawing disrespect of Chinese anthem

9:10 pm on 23 January 2019

Hong Kong has introduced a controversial bill that prescribes jail terms for disrespecting the Chinese national anthem.

Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Joshua Wong (L)  during a protest outside the Legislative Council, against a proposed law to punish anyone who disrespects the Chinese anthem with up to three years in jail.

Demonstrators show their opposition to a bill that includes jail terms for those who dishonour the Chinese national anthem. Photo: AFP

It is a move critics say raises fresh fears over freedom of expression in the city.

Chinese authorities have striven to instil greater patriotism in the former British colony at a time of heightened tension between democracy activists and forces loyal to Beijing, with some in Hong Kong even advocating independence from China.

Besides imprisonment, the measure would fix a maximum fine of HK$50,000 ($NZ9300) for those who publicly and intentionally disrespect the anthem, the March of the Volunteers.

It also extends to schoolchildren, including pupils of international schools, who would be legally required to learn the anthem.

"I think teachers would feel worried about this proposal, because if we allow this government to pass a law to instruct the teachers what to teach, well, this time it is for the national anthem, maybe next time it could be other things," said secondary school teacher Simon Hung, 36.

A Hong Kong pro-democracy activist holds a placard  during a protest outside the Legislative Council  in Hong Kong on January 23, 2019, against a proposed law to punish anyone who disrespects the anthem with up to three years in jail.

A pro-democracy activist at a demonstration outside the Legislative Council. Photo: AFP

Small groups of pro-democracy and pro-Beijing protesters taunted each other outside the Legislative Council, shouting and chanting through loud hailers.

Waving the red Chinese flag, pro-Beijing demonstrators held up banners that read: "Safeguard national dignity" and "Support the national anthem law," while democracy activists held placards that said: "Unsung freedom."

Booing the anthem at soccer matches in Hong Kong has emerged as a form of political protest in the past few years, seized upon by young people keen to demonstrate their frustration at Beijing's perceived creeping influence.

The global financial hub returned to Chinese rule in 1997 under a "one country, two systems" formula that promises the city a high degree of autonomy, including freedom of expression.

Proposal expected to become law within a few months

The anthem proposal is expected to pass easily when it comes to a vote later this year as the opposition does not have enough seats to block routine legislation.

Hong Kong has already outlawed the desecration of national flags and emblems, which can attract jail terms of three years.

Calls for outright independence are a red line for China's Communist Party leaders, who deem Hong Kong an inalienable part of the nation.

But many young people in Hong Kong have become increasingly angered by what they see as China's encroachment on the city's culture and autonomy, with some advocating "localism", or a Hong Kong identity, rather than a Chinese one.

"We have no sense of belonging to China at all," one football supporter told Reuters. "Even people I know who are born since 1997, they still think they are HongKongers, but not Chinese."

In 2017, mainland China adopted a law banning disrespect for the anthem. A similar measure is being reviewed in Macau, a former Portuguese-run enclave that returned to Chinese rule in 1999.

- Reuters