27 Apr 2025

Doves, deaths and rations: Papal elections over time

7:41 pm on 27 April 2025

By Alice Ritchie, AFP

Cardinals walk to take their places ahead of the late Pope Francis' funeral ceremony at St Peter's Square at The Vatican on April 26, 2025. (Photo by Mandel NGAN / AFP)

Cardinals walk to take their places ahead of the late Pope Francis' funeral ceremony at St Peter's Square at The Vatican on April 26, 2025. Photo: AFP/MANDEL NGAN

Cardinals electing Pope Francis's successor will have an easier time than many of their predecessors, who endured spartan conditions and were even locked up for so long that some of them died.

Here are some notable papal elections through the ages.

The dove decides

In 236, the Christian community of Rome was debating potential papal candidates when a white dove landed on the head of a bystander, Fabian.

White Dove perched on a post

Photo: 123rf

"At this, everyone, as if moved by a single divine inspiration, eagerly and wholeheartedly called out that Fabian was worthy," according to Eusebius, a Church historian of the era.

Saint Fabian and Saint Sebastian, wounded by arrows, are shown together with two tiny figures wearing black cloaks with hoods and white veils. Medieval Christians prayed to both saints as protectors against the plague.

Saint Fabian was pope in the third century and is shown wearing a papal tiara; he was martyred under the Roman Emperor Decius. Sebastian was tortured by the Emperor Diocletian who ordered his soldiers to tie him to a stake and shoot him with arrows. He survived, but was later beaten to death. Thick droplets of vivid red blood ooze from each of his wounds.

This painting was made in Siena, and it’s likely that it was commissioned by the religious group to which the little kneeling figures belonged. They may represent a group called the Bianchi – who had an altar dedicated to the saints in the eighteenth century – although they usually wore all white. This large panel may have originally been painted on both sides and carried in religious processions.

Pope Fabian. Photo: Wikipedia Commons / Giovanni di Paolo

The blessing was a mixed one for Fabian, who died 14 years later a martyr, persecuted by Emperor Decius.

Large-scale bribery

In the early Church, popes were elected by members of the clergy and the Roman nobility, and the votes were rife with meddling.

One of the most infamous elections was in 532, following the death of Boniface II, which involved "large-scale bribing of royal officials and influential senators", according to P.G. Maxwell-Stuart in "Chronicle of the Popes".

A Swiss guard stands with St Peter's Basilica in the background at St Peter's Square ahead of late Pope Francis' funeral in the Vatican on April 26, 2025. Pope Francis, champion of the poor and the Church's first Latin American leader, will be honoured April 26 with a funeral attended by world leaders and tens of thousands of Catholic faithful. The Argentine pontiff, who died on April 21, 2025, aged 88, sought to create a more open-minded Church during his 12-year papacy, and many emotional tributes have been made -- with 250,000 people paying respects at his coffin in St Peter's Basilica. (Photo by Alberto PIZZOLI / AFP)

A Swiss guard stands with St Peter's Basilica in the background at St Peter's Square ahead of late Pope Francis' funeral in the Vatican on 26 April 2025. Photo: Alberto Pizzoli / AFP

In the end, an ordinary priest was elected, Mercurius. He became the first pope to change his name - to John.

In 1059, Nicholas II gave cardinals sole authority to choose pontiffs.

Lock them up

The idea of locking up the cardinals to encourage a quick decision began in the 13th century - the word conclave comes from the Latin phrase meaning "with key".

In 1241, when the election was dragging on, the head of Rome's government locked the cardinals into a dilapidated building and refused to clean the lavatories or provide doctors for those who fell ill.

According to Frederic Baumgartner in his "Behind Locked Doors: A History of the Papal Elections", the cardinals only reached a decision after one of them died and the Romans threatened to exhume his corpse and have it make decisions.

After 70 days, they agreed on Goffredo Castiglioni, who became Celestine IV.

Three years

The longest conclave in history lasted almost three years following the death of Clement IV in November 1268, held in the papal palace at Viterbo, near Rome.

Palazzo dei Papi is a palace in Viterbo, region of Lazio, Italy. It is considered to be one of the most important monuments in the city, situated alongside the Duomo di Viterbo (Viterbo Cathedral).

Palace of the Popes in Viterbo. Photo: Wikipedia Commons / NikonZ7II

From late 1269 the cardinals allowed themselves to be locked in to try to reach a decision, and by June 1270, frustrated locals tore the roof off in a bid to speed things along.

They were apparently inspired by a quip by an English cardinal that without the roof, the Holy Spirit could descend unhindered.

Teobaldo Visconti became Pope Gregory X in September 1271.

Rations

In response to the chaos that led to his election, Gregory X changed the rules, requiring cardinals to meet within 10 days of the pope's death - and ordering that their food be reduced over time.

VATICAN CITY, VATICAN - APRIL 26: Cardinals attend the funeral of Pope Francis in St. Peter’s Square on April 26, 2025 in Vatican City, Vatican. Pope Francis died on April 21st at the age of 88. Born in Argentina as Jorge Mario Bergoglio, he was the first Latin American and the first Jesuit to become Pope when elected in 2013. Taking the name Francis after St Francis of Assisi, he promoted a more humble version of the papacy than many of his predecessors. He will be buried outside of the Vatican in a simple wooden coffin at the Basilica Santa Maria Maggiore.  (Photo by Dan Kitwood/Getty Images)

Cardinals attend the funeral of Pope Francis in St. Peter's Square on April 26, 2025 in Vatican City, Vatican. Photo: Dan Kitwood / Getty Images

If there was no decision in three days, meals were to be reduced to only one of the two traditional Italian main courses.

After five days, they would be cut back to just bread, water and wine, according to John L. Allen's book "Conclave".

Priests prepare the hosts ahead of the start of late Pope Francis' funeral ceremony in St Peter's Square at the Vatican on April 26, 2025. (Photo by Alberto PIZZOLI / AFP)

Priests prepare the hosts ahead of the start of late Pope Francis' funeral ceremony in St Peter's Square at the Vatican on 26 April 2025. Photo: Alberto Pizzoli / AFP

The cardinals were also barred from drawing on their incomes during a conclave.

Camp beds

Conclaves have for centuries been held in the Apostolic Palace and since 1878 in its Sistine Chapel.

A man visits the Sistine Chapel on the reopening day of the Vatican museum on February 1, 2021 in Vatican City, as the city-state eases its closure aimed at curbing the spread of the COVID-19 infection, caused by the new coronavirus. (Photo by Andreas SOLARO / AFP)

The famous frescoes of the Sistine Chapel form the backdrop of the conclave. Seen here on 1 February 2021. Photo: Andreas Solaro / AFP

Cardinals have in the past slept in the Apostolic Palace, with cubicles erected with camp beds, and one bathroom for every 10 electors, according to Allen's "Conclave".

The windows were sealed shut but in 1978, when the conclave took place during a stifling August, there was a near revolt by cardinals who demanded they be opened.

John Paul II - elected in a second conclave in that year, in October - ordered the construction of the $20 million Santa Marta guesthouse in the Vatican grounds, where Francis himself lived, and where the cardinals now stay.

Nuns pray at the statue of John Paul II outside the Gemelli University Hospital where Pope Francis is hospitalized with pneumonia, in Rome on March 01, 2025. Pope Francis, hospitalised for two weeks with pneumonia in both lungs, spent a peaceful night after suffering a breathing crisis, the Vatican said on March 01, 2025. (Photo by Tiziana FABI / AFP)

Nuns pray at the statue of John Paul II outside the Gemelli University Hospital. Photo: Tiziana Fabi / AFP

It has more than 100 guest suites and around two dozen single rooms.

But during the conclave there, too, the windows are sealed shut.

Non-cardinals

Technically any baptised male can become pope, but the last non-cardinal to be elected was the archbishop of Bari, Bartolomeo Prignano, who became Urban VI in 1378.

Reluctant pontiff

Not everyone is keen. The first words of Albino Luciani, on becoming John Paul I in 1978, were "May God forgive you for what you have done!"

Pope John Paul I (Jean Paul Ier, Jean-Paul), born Albino Luciani, sitting in a car during his only official visit from the Vatican to take possession of the Diocese of Rome. Rome, 23rd September 1978. ©MP/Portfolio/Leemage (Photo by leemage / Bridgeman Images via AFP)

Pope John Paul I, born Albino Luciani, is sitting in a car during his only official visit from the Vatican to take possession of the Diocese of Rome. Rome, 23 September 1978. Photo: Bridgeman Images / AFP

He died 33 days later.

Champagne

In 1978, after appearing to the crowds in St Peter's Square, John Paul II reportedly walked around pouring champagne for the cardinals and sang Polish folk songs.

In 2005, Benedict XVI invited all the cardinals to stay for dinner with champagne and there were also songs, the late cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor recalled afterwards.

(FILES) In this file photograph taken on December 25, 2005, Pope Benedict XVI delivers his first Christmas Day "Urbi et Orbi" (the city and the world) message to pilgrims and tourists on St Peter's Square at The Vatican. - Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, a German theologian whose 2013 resignation took the world by surprise, died on December 31, 2022, at age 95, the Vatican announced. (Photo by Vincenzo PINTO / AFP)

Pope Benedict XVI. File photo. Photo: VINCENZO PINTO / AFP

Shorter and shorter

The longest conclave in more recent times was that of 1831, which elected Gregory XVI after more than 50 days.

The longest of the 20th century, lasted only five days (14 ballots) when Pius XI was elected in 1922.

In 2005, Benedict XVI was elected in just two days (four ballots) and Francis in 2013 also in two days (five ballots).

- AFP

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs