Opinion: New Zealand’s relationship with India is in trouble

6:09 pm on 12 October 2022

By Geoffrey Miller for The Democracy Project*

India's external affairs minister Dr. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar met with Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern last week.

India's external affairs minister Dr. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar met with Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern last week. Photo: Supplied / Twitter / DrSJaishankar

Opinion - New Zealand's relationship with India is not in good health.

That's the underlying message from a rare visit to New Zealand by India's external affairs minister, Dr. Subrahmanyam Jaishankar.

Jaishankar met with his New Zealand counterpart, Nanaia Mahuta, last Thursday - but only for an hour.

At a press conference with Mahuta in Auckland, Jaishankar was publicly critical of New Zealand's unwillingness to renew visas for Indian students who had left New Zealand during the Covid-19 pandemic and called for 'fairer and more sympathetic treatment'.

Mahuta's response to the criticism was to pass the buck to Michael Wood, New Zealand's immigration minister, who was conveniently not present, and to point to hardships suffered by New Zealand students themselves.

Jaishankar reiterated his criticism at other engagements during his trip and on Twitter, and the comments dominated Indian media coverage of his five-day visit to Auckland and Wellington.

Despite the usual pleasantries, there was a sense that India had lost patience with New Zealand - a sentiment that was underlined by Jaishankar's later observation in Wellington of 'there is a larger world out there'.

Even more troubling from New Zealand's perspective was the extraordinary admission by Mahuta that a free trade agreement was 'not a priority for New Zealand or India'.

Instead, Mahuta could only point to potential economic cooperation in 'niche areas' such as digital services and 'green business' - a seemingly underwhelming approach that was endorsed by Jaishankar.

It is a far cry from the bold and ambitious India strategy that was launched by New Zealand to much fanfare in February 2020, when the then foreign affairs minister Winston Peters travelled to India.

The strategy, called 'Investing in the relationship', listed a free trade agreement as one of the major goals.

But the underlying theme of the blueprint was the need for a more long-term, sustained commitment by New Zealand to forging ties with the much larger India.

To this end, the plan called for 'more frequent high-level government engagements to build the trade, economic, political and security aspects of the relationship'.

Of course, the timing of the launch of the strategy turned out to be unfortunate. Within weeks of Peters' visit to New Delhi, most of the world had entered some form of lockdown to combat the Covid-19 pandemic.

But the overarching principle - that New Zealand needs to put far more time and effort into the India relationship, without necessarily expecting an immediate pay-off - still holds true.

Trade figures demonstrate the difficulties New Zealand's relationship with India is facing.

While New Zealand's exports to India were approaching NZ$2 billion annually in 2017, they have since collapsed to under NZ$800 million.

The impact of Covid-19 - which stopped Indian tourists and students coming to New Zealand - explains much of this slide, but by no means all of it. The initial decline actually began in 2018.

In fact, the deterioration has been so dramatic that India now ranks only 15th place in the list of New Zealand's biggest trading partners.

New Zealand's Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern stands next to India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the RCEP summit in Bangkok in 2019.

New Zealand's Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern stands next to India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the RCEP summit in Bangkok in 2019. Photo: RNZ

As recently as 2016, India was New Zealand's 10th biggest trading partner.

For comparison, New Zealand now sells less to India than it does to the United Arab Emirates.

Moreover, Jaishankar's forthright criticisms of New Zealand's handling of visas suggest that India is in no rush to encourage its citizens to head back to New Zealand now that the Covid-19 pandemic has eased.

Despite the warning signs, New Zealand's Labour Government has shown only limited interest in nurturing the relationship with India, even allowing for Covid-19 travel disruption.

To his credit, New Zealand's trade minister, Damien O'Connor, did at least fly to India last month, albeit only for a brief two-day visit.

But last week's visit by Jaishankar would have been an opportune moment for Jacinda Ardern to signal an intention to visit India herself - as she did with China in August.

But neither Ardern, nor Mahuta gave any hint that a visit to New Delhi is on the horizon.

Even when India's external affairs minister was in New Zealand, Ardern fitted in only a sideline meeting with him at an Indian community event in Auckland.

To find a contrast with New Zealand's experience, one only needs to look to Australia, which hosted Jaishankar this week.

A press conference between Jaishankar and Penny Wong, Australia's foreign minister, seemed particularly warm.

Wong was keen to point out that she had already met her Indian counterpart some seven times since she became foreign minister in May.

And from the Indian side, there was no parallel in Canberra to the criticisms Jaishankar had expressed about New Zealand's government while in Wellington and Auckland.

The Australia-India relationship has undoubtedly blossomed since the revival of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (or Quad for short, an arrangement that also includes Japan and the United States) in 2017, but there is more to it than just that.

Australia and India entered into a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership in 2020.

And this year, they signed a free trade deal with India that will eliminate tariffs on over 85 per cent of Australian exports.

The deal is not perfect - it includes wine and sheepmeat, but it completely excludes dairy.

Nevertheless, India is already Australia's seventh-biggest trading partner - and growing.

The current strength of India's relationship with Australia - and the relative weakness of ties with New Zealand - seems all the more remarkable when the current geopolitical faultline of Ukraine is brought into the equation.

Australia is one of Ukraine's biggest supporters - and one of the top 10 donors of military aid.

By contrast, India has a very different position on the war.

New Delhi has steadfastly avoided joining the Western-led coalition which is backing Kyiv.

Indeed, in Canberra, Jaishankar was quizzed by media on India's ongoing ties with Russia and its abstention in key UN votes criticising Moscow.

But the differences have not seemed to harm relations between Australia and India.

Instead, the two countries have effectively agreed to disagree on Ukraine and to work on shared interests in other areas.

In a time of extreme geopolitical polarisation, this is an achievement in itself.

While New Zealand has backed the West on Ukraine, it has done so in a more measured way than Australia - which in theory should make it easier to find common ground with India.

In Wellington, Jaishankar https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/jaishankar-inaugurates-new-indian-high-commission-chancery-in-wellington/article65988028.ece said New Zealand's relationship with India was 'due for refresh'].

He is not wrong.

But a reset will take time - and it will need leadership.

* Geoffrey Miller is the Democracy Project's international analyst and writes on current New Zealand foreign policy and related geopolitical issues. He has lived in Germany and the Middle East and is a learner of Arabic and Russian.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs