12 Aug 2022

Labour responds to Hamilton West MP Gaurav Sharma's allegations of bullying at Parliament

1:44 pm on 12 August 2022

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern spoke to media after claims from a backbench Labour MP that a culture of bullying is being supported by the groups intended to police it - including her office.

Watch the PM speaking here:

Ardern said what had been raised was, at its core, a dispute over employment issues within Sharma's office.

"As a result of that he has sought an alternative solution via different individuals - via the whips, via for instance a member in my office. But ultimately at its heart this relates to an employment matter within his office where we've sought to find resolution which hasn't always been welcomed," she said

She said Parliament, like any other workplace, must be free from bullying and that expectation applies to everyone, including MPs.

"Since the Francis report, we have better processes and procedures in place at Parliament, to identify concerns, intervene early to address them, and to help MPs to be good managers of staff - and that is exactly what has occurred here."

Labour's Whip's office earlier said it had always acted in good faith with Hamilton West MP Gaurav Sharma, after he made allegations about bullying at Parliament.

Ardern said the focus with Sharma from the start had been on a constructive approach to set him up for the long term as an MP, with coaching, mentoring and other supports.

"Starting out as a new MP can be challenging and one of the toughest parts is navigating the new environment but also the role you must play as an MP managing others."

The Parliamentary Service put a hiring pause on his office, she said, to "ensure that coaching and mentoring was constructive, and a way to resolve some of the issues in his office that had been raised".

She said she was confident successive Labour whips and Parliamentary Service had done their jobs appropriately.

"My primary concern at the moment is Gaurav's wellbeing. I've reached out to assure him that we will reach out with the support he feels he needs. Members of our team are in contact with him to make sure that he is okay.

From what she has observed, she had seen no evidence of "what's been framed as bullying" but rather, constructive long-term attempts to find a solution.

She said she had never worked with a better group of people, and while no one could claim perfection she was confident Sharma's concerns did not reflect a wider issue at Parliament.

In a statement earlier, chief whip Duncan Webb said his office became aware of issues between Dr Sharma and his staff a year ago, and had been trying to work with him to address issues between him and his staff as recently as yesterday.

He said hiring into Sharma's office had been paused to provide "further assistance".

"At all times the Whip's office has acted in good faith and sought to work constructively with Gaurav and the Parliamentary Service to ensure he has good support available to address issues between him and his staff.

"It recently paused hiring with the intention of providing further assistance before more staff were hired into his office. This seemed prudent. The Parliamentary Service and I met with Gaurav in good faith to progress these issues as recently as yesterday, he was fully represented at that meeting.

"We are mindful these are ongoing relationships, so we must respect individual's (sic) privacy."

The Whip said the office would continue to seek a resolution with Dr Sharma in the coming weeks.

No caption

Hamilton West MP Gaurav Sharma with PM Jacinda Ardern. File photo Photo: Twitter / Dr Gaurav Sharma

A column by Labour's MP for Hamilton West Gaurav Sharma, published in the NZ Herald, yesterday laid out a litany of complaints about a culture of bullying he said was supported by those intended to police such problems.

He levelled criticisms against the Prime Minister's Office, Labour's Whip's Office, the Parliamentary Service, and others.

"If any of my more recent colleagues could speak freely, I am sure the list of similar stories with no support for MPs being bullied and no consequences for MPs bullying their colleagues would easily fill a book or two," he wrote.

He said the Parliamentary Service stonewalled and ghosted MPs, and the party whips gaslit and victimised complainants.

The Parliamentary Service yesterday dismissed the allegations, saying it works alongside whips from all parties and had been working over the past year with Labour's Whip's office to address employment matters.

RNZ has contacted Sharma and the prime minister's office for comment.

Asked if Sharma himself was bullying, Ardern says she will not put a label on it. She said she became aware at the end of last year about the concerns and the next time it was raised with her was "in the media yesterday".

She said there were privacy concerns at play, and the employment matters needed to be resolved before assessing Sharma's approach to the problem.

"Our MPs employ up to three staff each, often two in their electorate and one in Wellington. That's a number of people that are engaged by our members of Parliament and I have a trusted relationship with the whips and the Parliamentary Services who are all involved in those employment relationships that they have good processes."

"What we also need to respect here is that there are other individuals involved and they are employment related, so we need to make sure we maintain some confidentiality for those parties too."

She rejected the suggestion the accusations would damage her personal brand of kindness in politics.

Sharma was still a valued member of the team, she said, "we wouldn't be working so hard to resolve these issues if he wasn't".

She has not had a chance to speak to him yet, she said.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs