An Onehunga resident says he has complained to Kāinga Ora for years about neglected dogs like this one at its properties, which he lives close to. Photo: Supplied
A neighbour of Kāinga Ora houses in Onehunga who has been bitten by an aggressive dog, tried to save a starving dog, and repeatedly notified the housing agency of his concerns about neglected pets, says Kāinga Ora doesn't intervene.
The man, who did not want to be named because of death threats from past tenants, told Checkpoint it was "impossible" to get action from Kāinga Ora over the heartbreaking scenes he had encountered during his decade living next door to the social housing.
On Monday Checkpoint revealed the plight of three dogs locked in a Kāinga Ora house in Bucklands Beach, Auckland, without food or water in filthy conditions including faeces and rats.
The dogs were eventually seized and euthanised. The tenant only had approval to keep one dog and pets had been seized from her before.
The Onehunga resident said he'd been complaining to Kāinga Ora about the neglected and malnourished pets of various tenants at neighbouring properties for years.
The complaints related to:
- Six dogs barking from a locked basement in the height of summer, with nobody home;
- A starved dog at another neighbouring Kāinga Ora property that the agency knew about but which the tenant did not have approval for;
- An aggressive dog which the resident raised several concerns about that eventually attacked him.
The man described the starved dog as looking as if it should weigh 30 kilograms but instead being about half the size.
"It's still got very little or no shelter. It's in a terrible condition. It's still caged in maybe an eight by 10 square metre back yard. It's not looked after."
Though a vet had now been to check the animal, the man approached the owner and offered to buy the dog so he could care for it.
The starving dog is kept in a small yard with little or no shelter. Photo: Supplied
He said Kāinga Ora admitted to knowing the dog was at the property despite the tenant not having approval for the animal.
"When we said we'd heard the dog had stopped barking maybe a month ago the response from Kāinga Ora was, why didn't I notify them as soon as I'd heard that the dog had stopped barking.
"So if we don't hear a dog barking we should contact them."
He said it was "actually impossible" to get any action from authorities except for the police when he and a neighbour discovered up to six dogs locked in a basement.
"We called Kāinga Ora and got no action. We called the council - they said they'd be out in a few days.
"The SPCA said it was a holiday weekend so they had no one on. And we eventually called the police who came and one of the policemen adopted the dog herself.
"In follow up Kāinga Ora didn't really seem to be responsible at all. It's always someone else's responsibility."
He said the police were great but it was not their responsibility, nor was it the job of animal control.
With the aggressive dog, the man said he repeatedly notified Kāinga Ora but nothing changed despite him having camera footage of the animal.
He was eventually attacked by the dog and described the lack of responsibility as "so frustrating".
Whose responsibility are the pets of Kāinga Ora tenants?
The man did not believe Kāinga Ora were keeping to their own animal policy.
This included that tenants needed permission to own a pet, must have a registered dog, couldn't have a menacing or nuisance dog and if it attacked anyone the tenant could be asked to remove it, a dog couldn't have puppies and the tenant couldn't be a disqualified owner.
"I think Kāinga Ora need to take some responsibility for the properties they have," the man said.
"The one next door has just been finished being fumigated for the flea infestation after the last tenants left with their pets."
He wanted regular inspections and pet policies enforced and suggested the Tenancy Tribunal be involved.
"They need to try something because what they are doing is not working.
"We've had death threats. We've had property damage. We've had... a dog waiting on our doorstep to attack us which the tenants let out.
"We've had a threat with a gun... This has stretched back with complaints over 10 years.
"The tenants there currently are great, but they have had some very disturbing behaviour in that property and it's been directed at us repeatedly."
Kāinga Ora general manager of national services Nick Maling said they expected tenants to be responsible pet owners.
"Those who want pets must first get Kāinga Ora's consent - they must agree to follow local council bylaws and to take responsibility for the containment, health, and wellbeing of their pet.
"But he says as a landlord, Kāinga Ora is not responsible for animal control.
"People should contact their local council for that - and for welfare issues contact SPCA."
He said once people had done that, they should then let Kāinga Ora know and if necessary, it could take action under the Residential Tenancies Act, Maling said.
SPCA general manager of animal services Corey Regnerus-Kell told Checkpoint animal welfare issues were the remit of the SPCA, unless there were more than 10 involved and then it was the responsibility of the Ministry for Primary Industries.
"If they're not getting food, shelter, water or if they're under any unnecessary pain, distress, or suffering, that's where the SPCA walks in.
"So we are looking after the sick, the injured and the vulnerable animals to try to make sure we can care for them, rehabilitate them and rehome them."
Under the Animal Welfare Act 1999 the SPCA could take animals from a property, but only if they were outside, he said.
Animals locked inside required a court-ordered search warrant to allow animal welfare inspectors to enter the property.
That would usually happen if no one was occupying the property or if the animal was suffering or starving.
Regnerus-Kell said a review of the Animal Welfare Act would be welcomed by the SPCA.
When asked about the three dogs at the Bucklands Beach property, Regnerus-Kell said he couldn't comment as it was still an open case.
"We did support and attend multiple occasions between December and March - we were on this property and speaking with the owners of the animals at this time."
He said it was Auckland Council who euthanised the dogs, not the SPCA.
Andrew Hoggard, the Associate Minister of Agriculture (Animal Welfare), was invited to talk to Checkpoint and declined.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
