5 Jul 2022

Postcode lottery for aged care admittance - research

9:44 am on 5 July 2022

Vulnerable people are being forced to wait too long for residential aged care beds and need much greater support when they are admitted, says new research pointing to a postcode lottery in the sector.

Depressed elderly widow sitting alone at home

Photo: 123rf

There had been an alarming lack of progress in providing timely residential care at the right level, in an equitable way across the country, the report by the New Zealand Aged Care Association found.

"The research shows that many older New Zealanders are both waiting too long to access the care they need, and access to that care depends on where they live," it said.

"Our postcode healthcare approach to caring for our older population must stop and is a critical challenge for the new health agencies going forward."

Association chief executive Simon Wallace said the aged care sector was facing devastating staffing shortages and a critical lack of registered nurses, forcing some providers to close beds or shut their doors entirely.

He said there had been a significant increase in the acuity or care level needed for the people admitted to residential care, without comparable increases in funding.

"Some providers are having to provide un-funded hospital level care to individuals in rest-home level beds, either because no beds that are certified to hospital level care are available, or the DHB is only funding the resident for rest-home level care when they need hospital-level care," he said.

The association analysed 2020/21 data from InterRAI, a clinical tool to assess older people's needs.

While the tool is mandatory, the report found district health boards' use of InterRAI was inconsistent and had declined over the past four years, contributing to the "postcode healthcare lottery".

Nationally, the report found an average of 46.3 percent of people were admitted to residential care within 12 months of meeting the assessment threshold, but that figure was just 28.2 percent in Tairāwhiti, based on 2019/20 data.

The association's clinical advisor and co-owner of Chatswood Retirement Village in Christchurch, Rhonda Sherriff, said people were going into aged care much later than they should be.

"I'm hearing on a daily basis that people are struggling to find care, find beds to be able to put loved ones," she said.

"It puts families under immense pressure because they're expected then obviously to step up and care for that person. There's a lot of stress and anxiety among people trying to access the right level of care."

Sheriff said the situation was particularly dire on the South Island's West Coast, where residential care providers were struggling to find registered nurses.

In the North Island, the distressed manager of a rural hospital last week told Sheriff she might be forced to close because of chronic staffing shortages.

"That particular manager was beside herself with worry," she said.

"She has the only facility in that area that actually provides care. If that were to close, then the residents who live in that area will have to be deployed elsewhere. They're out of their area then, and that's a really sad outcome."

The association wants the government to introduce a national, standard process by which people are assessed for support, including eligibility for residential care.

"New Zealand has an ageing population, and with the ongoing impact of the pandemic and nursing shortage on already stretched resources in the sector, change isn't an option, it's an imperative," the report said.

The new national health authority Te Whatu Ora Health NZ has accepted a report showing the aged care sector is short of beds and staff, saying it shows clear areas where improvement is needed.

In a statement, it said the research showed the areas where the national health system must address standards of support and delivery.

The agency welcomed the Aged Care Association's offer to work together.

Get the RNZ app

for ad-free news and current affairs