Is Auckland's development hamstrung by the view?

From Nine To Noon, 9:08 am on 23 October 2018

Auckland Council's policy to protect views is the most significant single barrier for growth in the city, an economist says.

Geoff Cooper has spent two years looking into a study on viewshafts and said one in particular was costing the city $1.4 billion worth of development.\

Called E-Ten, it gives southern-bound motorists on the northern motorway a view of the city, including Mount Eden.

Mr Cooper said he came up with the figure after comparing the difference in land values within the viewshaft and outside it.

"We think this [the figure] is very conservative - we're just measuring the land value," Mr Cooper said.

"On top of that... there's going to be all sorts of economic impacts when you allow developments to happen."

He said if the viewshaft was shifted slightly then more high-rise buildings, which could house more people, could be built.

"The problem is that Auckland wants to grow," he said.

"People want to live here and people want to work here [but] at the moment they can't."

"I can't think of a more significant single policy [that] is preventing the growth of Auckland city centre."

Woods Consultancy principal planner Phil Heffernan said he often has clients who were prevented from building high-rises because of viewshafts.

"One of the biggest sterilisers of a large scale development... is viewshafts," he said.

But John Duguid, Auckland Council's general manager of plans and places, said the $1.4 billion figure was overstated.

"That doesn't automatically convert to economic activity," he said.

"But I think Geoff's report does, in a couple of occasions, make the assumption that there will be significant increase in economic activity immediately, or very shortly after uplifting the viewshaft."

Auckland City view from Mt. Eden

Photo: 123rf

Mr Duguid said experts reviewed the location of viewshafts two years ago and concluded that the E-Ten viewshaft should stay.

He said Auckland Council was careful to try and have the right balance between protecting iconic Auckland views and allowing for development.

Viewshaft three dimensional plane

Viewshaft three dimensional plane Photo: Auckland Council

Get the RNZ app

for easy access to all your favourite programmes

Subscribe to Nine To Noon

Podcast (MP3) Oggcast (Vorbis)