5 Jul 2014

Beat your boys - paediatrician.

12:16 pm on 5 July 2014

An Australian paediatrician has been found guilty of professional misconduct by recommending that a father beat his twin sons "to within an inch" of their lives.

Consultant paediatrician David Evan Roberts was taken to Western Australia's Administrative Tribunal by the Medical Board over his treatment of the boys, whom he diagnosed with Attention Deficit Hyperative Disorder (ADHD) in 2008 when they were eight years old.

A hearing at the tribunal was told that after a consultation in 2010, Dr Roberts gave the boys' mother a note that said: "I recommend to your husband, that he beat (physically) each and any of your our (sic) sons who swear and offend his wife (that is Mother) ... to within in (sic) an inch of his life."

The Medical Board alleged the note had the potential to lead to the boys being subjected to corporal punishment, which could worsen their behaviour and contribute to the development of psychological or psychiatric problems.

But Dr Roberts denied the note was a recommendation for the parents to beat the children, the ABC reported.


He maintained he was speaking metaphorically, and that the note was a recommendation for the father to take an active role in defending his wife's honour, if the boys were physically and verbally aggressive towards her.

The note also referred to one of the boys as "a sooky la la" who needed to "toughen up, Princess".

Mother thanked doctor for care and support of children

Dr Roberts told the tribunal he deeply regretted the wording of the note, which "showed an appalling lack of judgement".

But he said that in 2011, the mother wrote to him, thanking him for his care and support of her children.

In its findings, the tribunal rejected Dr Roberts' explanation and found that "the note contained what the practitioner knew, or should have known, could have been taken as a recommendation that the patients' parents should use corporal punishment to discipline the patients".

"This put the patients' health, safety and welfare at risk," the tribunal said.

The tribunal has not yet issued a penalty for Dr Roberts.

The ABC reports that he intends to appeal against the findings.